Murphy looks forward to stepping down from his post as sheriff in Victor City. He's sure there's more to life than corralling drunks, disarming bandits, and clearing the streets of pickpockets. But before he leaves office Murphy must discover the truth of what happened during a stagecoach robbery that left three men dead and one man comatose. Katie Thomas is the only conscious survivor of the incident and swears she does not remember the event. Murphy wants to believe her but if she's telling the truth why do shifty characters keep turning up to ask her where she hid the money? It may be his last act as sheriff but Murphy determines to find out if beautiful Katie Thomas is as innocent as she looks.